Pulisic's goal was nullified by Ben Waine's last-minute equalizer in Cincinnati. The AC Milan winger expressed optimism that Pochettino can cultivate the intense mentality and bold approach the team requires to excel on the biggest stage.
The Argentine coach, who left American-owned Premier League side Chelsea in May after one season in charge, will lead the team ahead of the 2026 World Cup, co-hosted by the U.S., Mexico, and Canada.
The U.S. have been without a permanent coach since a humiliating early exit from the Copa America on home soil in July led to the sacking of Gregg Berhalter after his second stint as head coach.
"It's time to turn the page. We really have to pick it up a level," Pulisic told reporters late on Tuesday.
"It feels pretty low right now, but I know there's better times ahead. Hopefully he (Pochettino) brings a culture that is willing to fight, that is willing to take risks and win.
"There are a lot of things that need to change, just the mentality and the culture of the group. I think we have the quality but I know that is the first thing that he is going to want to change."
Pochettino, a former Paris St Germain and Tottenham Hotspur manager, said his decision to join U.S. soccer was not just about football, but about the journey the country was on and he could not pass up the opportunity.
The U.S. next play friendlies against Panama on Oct. 12 and Mexico three days later.